White Paper

1.2 A High-Level Overview of the QuerySurge Solution

QuerySurge is positioned as a fully automated, end-to-end solution for data validation and Extract, Transform, Load (ETL) testing. Its specialized BI Tester module is explicitly designed to address the complexities and challenges of validating data within BI reports and dashboards, including those created in Microsoft Power BI.³

By providing a dedicated framework for automated testing, QuerySurge offers a viable and scalable alternative to traditional, manual testing methods, which are frequently prone to human error and a significant drain on valuable resources.⁴

The solution supports a range of critical testing activities, including regression testing of BI data, migration testing between different BI vendors, and validation during version upgrades.⁴ This capability to ensure data accuracy across the entire data pipeline, from source to the final BI report, is crucial for maintaining data quality and stakeholder confidence.⁴

2.2 The Financial and Strategic Costs of Bad Data

The risks of relying on poor data quality are pervasive and far-reaching. As noted, the financial cost can amount to millions of dollars annually, but the impact extends beyond direct monetary loss.⁶ Flawed data leads to flawed insights, which in turn lead to poor business decisions that can compromise a company's competitive advantage in a challenging market.⁶ Undetected data errors can result in significant regulatory fines, loss of customer trust, and reputational damage.¹ These are not just technical problems; they are strategic business challenges that can tank an entire project and undermine corporate credibility.⁴

The imperative to validate BI reports, therefore, is rooted in the need to build and maintain a foundation of trust. By ensuring the data that powers analytics is accurate, organizations can shift from a reactive state of "data fire-fighting" to a proactive state of quality assurance.¹ This enables business leaders to make decisions with confidence, accelerates project delivery cycles, and ultimately fuels innovation and growth.¹

2.3 Introduction to the QuerySurge BI Tester

QuerySurge's BI Tester module provides a purpose-built solution to overcome the significant challenges posed by manual BI report validation.⁴ It is an automated, end-to-end platform that handles the entire testing lifecycle, from data extraction to comparison and reporting.³ The BI Tester module is specifically designed to retrieve data from visualizations within a Power BI report and validate it against a trusted source, which could be a data warehouse, a database, a flat file, or another report.⁴

This automated approach facilitates a variety of critical use cases that are difficult to execute manually. These include:

• Business Validation: Ensuring the data presented to business users is accurate and reliable.
• Full Regression Testing: Running comprehensive tests to ensure that changes to the underlying data pipeline or report logic have not introduced new defects.
• Migration Testing: Validating data integrity during a migration from one BI vendor to another.
• Upgrade Testing: Ensuring data accuracy after a new version of a report is deployed.⁴
  

3.2 Types of Data Comparisons: Row Count, Column, and Table-Level

QuerySurge offers a flexible suite of comparison methods to cater to various testing needs, from a high-level health check to a granular, record-by-record validation.¹³ The three primary types of data comparisons are:

• Row Count Comparison: This is the quickest and most straightforward test, used to verify that the number of records in the source and target datasets match. It is an ideal initial check to ensure no records were lost or duplicated during the data flow.¹⁴
• Column-Level Comparison: This method provides granular validation for specific columns. It is particularly useful for validating data in columns that undergo no transformation, which on average make up about 80% of a dataset. This approach allows testers to focus their efforts on key data points.¹⁴
• Table-Level Comparison: This is a comprehensive, end-to-end comparison of two full tables. It is an excellent choice for data migration projects or database upgrades where there are no transformations, allowing for a simultaneous and rapid comparison of many tables to ensure complete data integrity.¹⁴

By providing these different comparison types, QuerySurge allows teams to tailor their testing strategy to the specific requirements of each project, balancing speed with the required level of data coverage.

3.3 Configuring Power BI Connections in QuerySurge

To begin validating a Power BI report, a connection must be first established within the QuerySurge Admin view.⁸ This configuration is a critical step that dictates how QuerySurge will authenticate and interact with the Power BI Service. The research material identifies two primary methods for this: the Master User and the Service Principal.

The Master User approach involves using the credentials (username and password) of a Power BI user to authenticate the embedded solution.¹⁶ While this method might seem simple, it is flagged as "not as secure" and has significant operational drawbacks.¹⁶ For instance, if the employee's role or password changes, the authentication token is invalidated, requiring manual re-authentication and causing potential disruptions to the automated testing pipeline.¹⁷ This approach is tied to an individual's account, which introduces a single point of failure and makes it challenging to manage in a large, dynamic enterprise environment.

In stark contrast, the Service Principal method is explicitly recommended as the "Microsoft Entra ID recommended authorization method" for secure, enterprise-level integrations.¹⁶ With this method, authentication tokens are linked to a registered application rather than an individual user, ensuring that the connection remains valid even if a team member's role or access changes.¹⁷ The process of setting up a Service Principal is more involved but provides a far more secure and stable foundation for a continuous testing strategy. The setup requires creating a new Microsoft Entra app registration, a dedicated security group, and enabling specific developer settings in the Power BI Admin portal, such as "Allow service principals to use Power BI APIs".¹⁷ This approach is essential for any organization with strict security protocols, as it allows for fine-grained control over access permissions without exposing individual user credentials. This level of granular control and security is a hallmark of a robust, professional-grade solution and is a key reason why the Service Principal is the preferred method for long-term, enterprise-wide adoption.

4.2 Connecting to Power BI Workspaces and Reports

The wizard’s first step is to guide the user in selecting the specific report to be tested. After a Power BI connection has been configured, QuerySurge automatically fetches a list of all available workspaces and reports that the authenticated user or service principal has access to.¹⁹

A visual representation of the wizard's "Report Selection Page" would show two drop-down menus. The first, labeled "Workspace (Required)," would list all available workspaces. Once a workspace is selected, the second drop-down, labeled "Report (Required)," would populate with all the reports within that chosen workspace. This screen demonstrates the foundational simplicity of the wizard, as the user only needs to click to select their target.

After the report is chosen and loaded, the wizard renders the Power BI report directly within its interface. A key usability feature is that all valid visualizations—those that QuerySurge can extract data from—are highlighted, typically in red.¹⁹ This visual cue helps testers quickly identify which elements of the report can be included in their tests, eliminating guesswork and speeding up the test design process. A visual representation of this screen would show a Power BI report with a number of charts, tables, and graphs, with some of them outlined in a distinct color to indicate their testability.

4.3 Generating Queries for Visualizations and Slicers

The central functionality of the Power BI Wizard is its ability to generate the necessary H2 SQL to query a visualization. This is a no-code process that is as simple as a right-click. A user simply right-clicks on a highlighted visualization within the wizard's interface, which brings up a context menu with several options.¹⁹

The options presented are: "Copy," "Replace in Editor," "View SQL," and "View Details".¹⁹ The most powerful of these, "Replace in Editor," automatically inserts the generated SQL directly into the Source or Target query pane, overwriting any existing logic.¹⁹ The "View SQL" option opens a modal that displays the generated H2 SQL, providing a clear view of the underlying function call and its parameters.¹⁹

The wizard's design extends beyond a basic query to handle complex report elements like Slicers (filters).¹⁹ Slicers, which filter data at the page level and affect all linked visualizations, represent a major challenge for manual testing, as a tester must manually record and reapply filter settings for each test run. The wizard automates this process. When generating a query, the user has the option to include the current state of all Slicers. The wizard automatically incorporates this filter information into the generated SQL, making the test repeatable and robust regardless of the report's default state.¹⁹ This capability is instrumental in making test maintenance significantly easier and more reliable.

For example, consider a sample dataset with a SalesAmount column, a ProductCategory column, and a Region column. A Power BI report visualizes this data. If a user selects a "Category" slicer to filter for "Electronics" and then uses the wizard to generate a query for a table visualization, the resulting H2 SQL query will include the filter information. A sample of such a query might appear as follows:

SELECT "ProductCategory", "SalesAmount", "Region" 
FROM powerbiReport(
'12345678-abcd-1234-abcd-1234567890ab', 
'98765432-efgh-9876-efgh-9876543210fe', 
'Sales Dashboard', 'Sales Table', true
) 
WHERE "ProductCategory" = 'Electronics'

4.4 Incorporating Row-Level Security into Wizard-Generated Queries

Many enterprise Power BI reports implement Row-Level Security (RLS) to restrict data access based on the user viewing the report.¹⁹ The Power BI Wizard is designed to handle this critical security feature.

The powerbiReport function, which is the core of the generated queries, includes optional parameters for userName and roles.8 By passing a specific username and a comma-separated list of roles, QuerySurge can emulate the view of a particular user, ensuring that the test is conducted with the correct data permissions and accurately validates what a specific user sees.⁸ This is a crucial capability for validating reports that are subject to strict data access policies, ensuring that security-related data filters are working as intended.

5.3 Advanced Querying: Joins, Aggregates, and Aliases

The power of the powerbiReport function lies in its ability to be used within more complex queries. For example, a tester can write a query that joins data from a Power BI report with data from a different database to perform an end-to-end validation. The function can also be used in conjunction with aggregate functions to validate summarized metrics. A tester could, for instance, calculate the sum of sales from a source database and compare it to the sum calculated from a Power BI visualization using GROUP BY and an aggregate function, thereby validating complex transformation logic.⁸

5.4 Important Limitations and Practical Workarounds

A comprehensive understanding of any tool requires recognizing its limitations. The QuerySurge BI Tester for Power BI has several key constraints that must be considered when designing a testing strategy:

• Report Types: The tool supports data extraction only from Power BI Reports. Dashboards and Paginated Reports are not supported at this time.⁸
• Visualization Limitations: The tool does not support data extraction from Custom Visualizations.⁸
• Export Limits: All visualizations have an export limit of 30,000 records. Any data beyond this threshold will not be included in the QuerySurge comparison.⁸ Similarly, for DirectQuery sources, the maximum data export is limited to 16 MB.⁸

These export limits are not minor technical details; they have significant implications for a testing strategy. For large datasets, a tester cannot simply rely on the BI Tester to validate every single record. Instead, for reports with datasets exceeding these limits, a more strategic approach is required. The primary strategy should be to leverage QuerySurge’s core ETL testing capabilities to validate the data at its source (e.g., in the data warehouse) before it is loaded into Power BI. The BI Tester can then be used to perform a representative "health check" on key metrics and aggregate values within the report, a practical compromise when full data coverage at the visualization layer is not feasible. This ensures a high level of data quality assurance throughout the data pipeline, with the BI Tester serving as the final validation point for the user-facing report layer.

6.2 Case Study in Practice: Validating a 10 Billion-Record Migration

The real-world application of QuerySurge’s capabilities is powerfully demonstrated in the case study with Atos, a global leader in digital transformation.²¹ Atos was tasked with validating a database migration for a large telecommunications company that involved over 10 billion records, all to be completed within a tight project timeline of just a few months. Given the immense volume and the limited time, a manual comparison was not a viable option.²¹

The Atos team implemented QuerySurge as the central component of their automated testing solution. They categorized the tables by priority and criticality and created a suite of 421 QueryPairs to perform the validations.²¹ A single test validated a table with up to 4.8 billion records, and the total number of records validated across all tests reached over 9.2 billion.²¹ QuerySurge was able to quickly identify issues, which were then resolved by the development team and re-verified by re-running the tests.²¹

This case study is a testament to the scalability and reliability of the QuerySurge platform. It is not merely a list of impressive metrics; it is a narrative of how the solution directly addressed a high-stakes business problem. The successful outcome provided the client with the confidence to proceed with the migration, and they were so impressed with the solution that they are now considering implementing it across other data testing efforts.²¹ This proves that the promised speed, coverage, and ROI are not just marketing claims but are achievable and repeatable in a real-world, enterprise-level environment.

6.3 The ROI of Automated Data Validation: A Financial Model

7.2 The QuerySurge Architecture: Application Server, Agents, and Database

Understanding the QuerySurge architecture provides clarity on how the platform achieves its speed, scalability, and security.²⁷ The system is built on a distributed architecture consisting of three main components:

• Application Server: This component acts as the central hub, managing user sessions, authentication, and orchestrating test executions.²⁷
• Database Server: This is where all the data comparisons and test data storage occur. QuerySurge includes a fully managed, built-in database server, eliminating the need for a separate setup and reducing the reliance on internal database administrators.²⁷
• Agents: These are the workhorses of the system. Agents are deployed to execute queries against source and target data stores using JDBC drivers. They retrieve the data and return it to the QuerySurge server for analysis.²⁷ A key advantage of this design is that adding more agents increases testing throughput, allowing for greater concurrency and scalability to handle large data volumes.²⁷

This architectural design, combined with the ability to deploy agents as Docker containers, provides the flexibility to meet diverse infrastructure needs, whether on a bare metal server, a virtual machine, or a private cloud environment.²⁷

7.3 Analytics and Reporting: Turning Test Results into Actionable Insights

The value of data validation extends beyond a simple pass/fail result. QuerySurge offers a suite of data analytics tools to turn complex test data into clear, actionable insights.¹¹ The platform's real-time Data Analytics Dashboard allows users to build custom visualizations and assess testing status, team productivity, and project health at a glance.¹¹

Beyond the dashboard, a comprehensive suite of Data Intelligence Reports provides in-depth, configurable analysis. A critical feature is Root Cause Analysis, which allows testers to quickly identify and isolate the source of an issue, drilling down to the specific column that caused a test to fail.¹¹ These reports can be filtered by date, asset type, or specific execution and are exportable in various formats, enabling seamless sharing with stakeholders.¹¹ This capability ensures that the results of data validation are not just numbers but are valuable intelligence that drives better decision-making and continuous improvement.

8.2 Summary of Key Benefits

Based on the evidence presented, the core benefits of using QuerySurge for Power BI validation can be summarized as follows:

• Speed: The solution is capable of accelerating data validation by up to 1,000 times compared to manual testing, drastically shortening the time to production.⁶
• Coverage: QuerySurge enables testers to achieve up to 100% data validation, eliminating the risks and uncertainties associated with random data sampling.¹
• Efficiency: The Power BI Wizard and AI-powered features dramatically reduce test creation time and lower the required technical skillset, saving hundreds of hours of manual labor.¹⁴
• ROI: The platform delivers a proven, quantifiable return on investment, with one model showing a labor-cost-based ROI of 877% over three years.²
• Integration: QuerySurge is designed to be a core component of a modern data pipeline, with extensive API and webhook support that allows it to seamlessly integrate into DevOps and CI/CD workflows.²²

8.3 Recommendations for Successful Adoption and Implementation

For any organization considering a data validation solution for Power BI, a pragmatic and phased approach is recommended. The first step should be to engage with the product through its free trial or a Proof of Concept (PoC).⁴ A PoC offers a low-risk opportunity to test QuerySurge against an organization's actual data pipelines and business rules, validating its ability to find real-world data issues and demonstrating its value in a specific environment.²⁸ This initial engagement allows teams to evaluate the platform's ease of use, assess its integration capabilities with existing tools, and build a customized financial model that proves the return on investment for their specific use case.²⁸ A successful PoC provides a clear, data-driven justification for full-scale adoption, de-risking the investment and ensuring that the solution aligns with the organization's technical goals and budget expectations.